Russia’s Foreign Policy Progressives Have Trumped The Traditionalists

Russia’s foreign policy “rebalancing” is the result of its progressive “deep state” faction obtaining more influence than the traditionalist one in deciding grand strategy.

Many observers of Russian foreign policy have been left confused over the past couple of years as Moscow’s deft geostrategic maneuverings in the “Ummah” caught them completely off guard, as they never expected for Russia’s “Pivot/Rebalancing to Asia” to take on Muslim proportions in South-Central Eurasia. Most of these same people have difficulty accepting Russia’s moves, and instead have sought to either ignore, downplay, or craft outlandish conspiracy theories about them. The partnerships drawing the most controversy are those which Russia has recently reached with Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Azerbaijan, and Pakistan, and the reason why they’ve created such a fuss is because they fly straight in the face of everything that the foreign policy “traditionalists” stand for.

The “progressive” faction of the Russian “deep state” (permanent military, intelligence, and diplomatic bureaucracies) understands that their country needs to flexibly adapt to the full-spectrum paradigm changes taking place across the globe as the emerging Multipolar World Order progressively enters into force. This means reconceptualizing Russia’s 21st-century geostrategic role and perceiving it as striving to become the supreme balancing force in the Eurasian supercontinent, which necessitates reaching mutually advantageous arrangements with non-traditional partners. The traditionalists, however, believe that Russia shouldn’t ever diversify from its existing partners in any way that could even remotely upset them, which symbolizes their extremely dogmatic and unflinching approach to the issue.

These traditionalists think that Russia either isn’t serious about its newfound partnerships or is engaging in them out of desperation to “keep one’s enemies close”, refusing to acknowledge that Moscow is actually very committed to deepening relations with each of its new partners and has sincere intentions to enter into multiple trust-building initiatives with them. For example, it’s ridiculous to suggest that Russia’s S-400 (military), Turkish/Balkan Stream (energy), and Astana (diplomatic) ties with Turkey are anything but genuine and designed to bring the two sides closer than at any moment in their histories. The same goes for its OPEC, investment, and potential arms ties with Saudi Arabia; its all-around strengthened partnership with Azerbaijan; and its rapid rapprochement with Pakistan.

All of these moves have shocked the traditionalists, who are fearful that their country has “betrayed” its beloved Syrian, Iranian, Armenian, and Indian partners due to the “irresponsible” forays of the progressives, but that’s not true at all since it was in reality the latter two states which “betrayed” Russia, as the author explained in his recent article questioning whether “Armenia, India, And Serbia Are ‘Balancing’ Against Russia Or ‘Betraying’ It?”. Even in this case, however, Russia still isn’t “betraying” anybody, since it’s simply diversifying and updating its international relationships for in line with the 21st-century geopolitics of the New Cold War in order to better “balance” the affairs of the Eurasian supercontinent, which is also the reason why it’s moved so close to Turkey and Saudi Arabia too in spite of the inferred uncomfortableness that this might make some in Syria and Iran feel.

Given the astounding geostrategic progress that Russia has made in the past couple of years in turning itself into a real force to be reckoned with in the Ummah, it’s extraordinarily unlikely and actually all but impossible that it will backtrack on its latest gains and revert back to the outdated mode of thinking that the traditionalists want it to abide by. The progressives “run the roost”, so to speak, and they’ve made it abundantly clear on numerous occasions that none of these exciting new partnerships are to the “zero-sum” disadvantage of anyone else; rather, they epitomize the “win-win” logic that modern-day multipolarity is becoming known for, whether observers recognize it right now or sometime later on.

If Russia is successful in retaining its “legacy” partnerships while strengthening the new ones that it’s worked hard to acquire, then the traditionalist-progressive “deep state” dichotomy might give way to a single class of “balancers/managers” in the future as Moscow finally fulfills its envisioned 21st-century geostrategic role in Eurasia.

Russian FM Sergey Lavrov greeting his Saudi counterpart in Moscow, June 2016
Russian FM Sergey Lavrov greeting his Saudi counterpart in Moscow, June 2016

DISCLAIMER: The author writes for this publication in a private capacity which is unrepresentative of anyone or any organization except for his own personal views. Nothing written by the author should ever be conflated with the editorial views or official positions of any other media outlet or institution. 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
111 Comments
  1. Pingback: The Rohingya Crisis: Conflict Scenarios And Reconciliation Proposals | OrientalReview.org

  2. Pingback: The Rohingya Crisis: Conflict Scenarios and Reconciliation Proposals |  SHOAH

  3. Pingback: Does anyone still seriously think that Russia and Israel aren’t allies – Emma Olive

  4. Good article. It is all about dialectics vs dogmatism…

  5. Pingback: Russia’s New Thinking Towards Armenia And Azerbaijan: An “Obstructionist” vs. An “Integrationalist” | OrientalReview.org

  6. Pingback: Russia’s New Thinking Towards Armenia and Azerbaijan: An “Obstructionist” vs. an “Integrationalist” – Counter Information

  7. Pingback: Crise des « Rohingyas »: scénarios de conflit, et propositions de réconciliation | Réseau International

  8. Pingback: Russia’s Kurdish-Turkish Pipeline To The EU Makes Moscow The Mideast Mediator | OrientalReview.org

  9. Pingback: Ендрју Корибко: Геополитика мултиполарног поретка 21. века | Патриот

  10. Pingback: Le pipeline turco-kurde de la Russie à l’UE fait de Moscou le médiateur du Moyen-Orient | Ombre43

  11. Pingback: Is Saudi Arabia’s Grand Strategy Shifting? – Independent News Media

  12. Pingback: Is Saudi Arabia's Grand Strategy Shifting? | ValuBit News

  13. Pingback: Is Saudi Arabia’s Grand Strategy Shifting? | ProTradingResearch

  14. Pingback: Is Saudi Arabia’s Grand Strategy Shifting? – The Conservative Insider

  15. Pingback: Is Saudi Arabia's Grand Strategy Shifting? | Newzsentinel

  16. Pingback: Is Saudi Arabia's Grand Strategy Shifting? | StockTalk Journal

  17. Pingback: Is Saudi Arabia’s Grand Strategy Shifting? | Wall Street Karma

  18. Pingback: Is Saudi Arabia’s Grand Strategy Shifting? | Economic Crisis Report

  19. Pingback: Uzbekistan’s New President Mirziyoyev Is Undoing Karimov’s Legacy. Towards a Rapprochement with Moscow and Beijing? – Counter Information

  20. Pingback: Is It Time For “Food Diplomacy” In Venezuela? – OrientalReview.org

  21. Pingback: Is It Time for “Food Diplomacy” in Venezuela? |  SHOAH

  22. Pingback: Is It Time for “Food Diplomacy” in Venezuela? – Counter Information

  23. Pingback: Shoigu’s Set To Strengthen The Russian-“Israeli” Strategic Partnership – OrientalReview.org

  24. Pingback: Strengthening the Russia-Israeli “Strategic Partnership”, Russia’s Defense Minister Shoigu Visits Israel – Counter Information

  25. Pingback: India Mimics America And Hints At A Russian Twitter Troll Conspiracy – OrientalReview.org

  26. Pingback: India ‘Elites’ Mimic Washington: Claim Russian ‘Twitter Troll’ Is Backing Opposition Party | ProTradingResearch

  27. Pingback: India ‘Elites’ Mimic Washington: Claim Russian ‘Twitter Troll’ Is Backing Opposition Party – Independent News Media

  28. Pingback: India ‘Elites' Mimic Washington: Claim Russian ‘Twitter Troll' Is Backing Opposition Party | WarMachines.com

  29. Pingback: India ‘Elites’ Mimic Washington: Claim Russian ‘Twitter Troll’ Is Backing Opposition Party | Wall Street Karma

  30. Pingback: India 'Elites' Mimic Washington: Claim Russian 'Twitter Troll' Is Backing Opposition Party | Newzsentinel

  31. Pingback: India ‘Elites’ Mimic Washington: Claim Russian ‘Twitter Troll’ Is Backing Opposition Party | Investing Daily News

  32. Pingback: India ‘Elites’ Mimic Washington: Claim Russian ‘Twitter Troll’ Is Backing Opposition Party | Real Patriot News

  33. Pingback: India Mimics America and Hints at a Russian Twitter Troll Conspiracy – Counter Information

  34. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM – OrientalReview.org

  35. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM - Yesterday's Prophecy, Today's News

  36. Pingback: Camilo Arcaya» Internacionales » Strengthening the Russia-Israeli “Strategic Partnership”, Russia’s Defense Minister Shoigu Visits Israel

  37. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM | ProTradingResearch

  38. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM | ValuBit News

  39. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM - Tradebuddy.online Stockmarket news - Forex - News - Realtime market Data- World News - Trading Ideas

  40. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM | Real Patriot News

  41. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM - Political American

  42. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM | StockTalk Journal

  43. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM | WarMachines.com

  44. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM | Wall Street Karma

  45. Pingback: Today’s News 28th October 2017 | The One Hundredth Monkey

  46. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM | GEOECONOMIST

  47. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM | Economic Crisis Report

  48. Pingback: Est-il temps pour une diplomatie alimentaire au Venezuela ? | Ombre43

  49. Pingback: Saudi’s burgeoning relations with Israel could kill the two state solution in more ways than one – aladdinsmiraclelamp

  50. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM – OrientalReview.org – Peter Degedo

  51. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM – OrientalReview.org | SAVIOR.NEWS

  52. Pingback: Saudi Arabia Could Acknowledge Israel Because of Of NEOM –… | CENSORED.TODAY

  53. Pingback: Est-il temps pour une diplomatie alimentaire au Venezuela ? | Réseau International

  54. Pingback: Saudi’s Burgeoning Relations With Israel Could Kill The Two State Solution In More Ways Than One – Liberty Front Press

  55. Pingback: Saudi Zio-Wahhabi regime Might Recognize Israel Because Of NEOM |  SHOAH

  56. Pingback: En Russie, les progressistes de la politique étrangère l’ont emporté sur les traditionalistes | Ombre43

  57. Pingback: Russia’s Iranian Energy Deal Killed Four Birds With One Stone – OrientalReview.org

  58. Pingback: Did Russia’s Iranian Energy Deal Kill Four Birds With One Stone? | ProTradingResearch

  59. Pingback: Did Russia's Iranian Energy Deal Kill Four Birds With One Stone? | ValuBit News

  60. Pingback: Did Russia's Iranian Energy Deal Kill Four Birds With One Stone? | Newzsentinel

  61. Pingback: Did Russia's Iranian Energy Deal Kill Four Birds With One Stone? | StockTalk Journal

  62. Pingback: Did Russia’s Iranian Energy Deal Kill Four Birds With One Stone? – Independent News Media

  63. Pingback: Did Russia’s Iranian Energy Deal Kill Four Birds With One Stone? | Investing Daily News

  64. Pingback: Did Russia's Iranian Energy Deal Kill Four Birds With One Stone? | Rightsource News

  65. Pingback: Did Russia’s Iranian Energy Deal Kill Four Birds With One Stone? – The Conservative Insider

  66. Pingback: Is Saudi Arabia’s Grand Strategy Shifting? – OrientalReview.org

  67. Pingback: Vers où va-t-on?:En souvenir : Harvey Weinstein | actualitserlande

  68. Pingback: La géopolitique du nouvel ordre mondial multipolaire du XXIe siècle | Réseau International

  69. Pingback: Vers où va-t-on ?Est-ce que quelqu’un pense encore sérieusement que la Russie et Israël ne sont pas alliés ? | actualitserlande

  70. Pingback: The Next People-To-People Phase Of The Russian-Pakistani Rapprochement | OrientalReview.org

  71. Pingback: ГЕОПОЛИТИКА МУЛТИПОЛАРНОГ ПОРЕТКА 21. ВЕКА – Novi Standard

  72. Pingback: India Could Cordially Compete With China Through BRICS+ | OrientalReview.org

  73. Pingback: Here’s Why Russia Might Set Up a Red Sea Base in Sudan - SomTribune

  74. Pingback: Here’s Why Russia Might Set Up a Red Sea Base in Sudan | ethiopanorama.com | ethiopanorama.com

  75. Pingback: Putin Announces Partial Withdrawal Of Forces In Syria, US Intends To Stay - Alternative Report

  76. Pingback: Russia’s Military Withdrawal Will Prompt President Assad To “Compromise” – Novus Vero

  77. Pingback: Russia's Military Withdrawal Will Prompt President Assad To “Compromise” | ValuBitNews

  78. Pingback: Russia's Military Withdrawal Will Prompt President Assad To "Compromise" | ValuBit

  79. Pingback: Russia’s Military Withdrawal Will Prompt President Assad To “Compromise” | Investing Daily News

  80. Pingback: Russia’s Military Withdrawal Will Prompt President Assad To “Compromise” | Real Patriot News

  81. Pingback: Russia's Military Withdrawal Will Prompt President Assad To “Compromise” | ProTradingResearch

  82. Pingback: Russia's Military Withdrawal Will Prompt President Assad To “Compromise” – Wall Street Karma

  83. Pingback: La déclaration de l’OCI permet à la Russie de piloter la Solution à Deux États | Réseau International

  84. Pingback: It’s Time For Pakistan To Join The Eurasian Development Bank | OrientalReview.org

  85. Pingback: Will Washington's Veiled NSS Threats against Pakistan Contribute to Consolidating Its Economic Alignment with China … | Donald J. Trump No. 45

  86. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete's Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie | ValuBitNews

  87. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete's Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie | ValuBit

  88. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete's Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie | StockTalk Journal

  89. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete’s Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie – Novus Vero

  90. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete’s Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie – Independent News Media

  91. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete's Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie | Zero Hedge

  92. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete’s Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie | Investing Daily News

  93. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete’s Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie | Economic Crisis Report

  94. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete’s Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie | OrientalReview.org

  95. Pingback: Trump Saved St. Pete’s Because He Wants A Piece Of The Syrian Pie – The Deplorable Patriots

  96. Pingback: | NavalBrasil.com

  97. Pingback: Trump: Agent Of Chaos? | Real Patriot News

  98. Pingback: Trump: Agent of Chaos (a.k.a. “The Kraken”) – Counter Information

  99. Pingback: Reconceptualizing Iran’s Role in Eurasia | OrientalReview.org

  100. Pingback: LES CONTOURS DU NOUVEL ORDRE MONDIAL – BibiCabaya

  101. Pingback: Now's the Chance to Clinch a Russia-Pakistan Military Partnership  | CommandEleven

  102. Pingback: Russia Might "Pivot To Africa" With "Mercenaries" | StockTalk Journal

  103. Pingback: Russia Might “Pivot To Africa” With “Mercenaries” – The Conservative Insider

  104. Pingback: The US’ Boast that NK Sanctions are Meant to Kill Puts RF and PRC on the Spot - Regional Rapport

  105. Pingback: Will American Missiles Destroy The Russian-Japanese Rapprochement? | OrientalReview.org

  106. Pingback: Russia Might “Pivot To Africa” With “Mercenaries” | Isenberg Institute of Strategic Satire

  107. Pingback: Is It Even Possible To “Betray” The Kurds? | OrientalReview.org

  108. Pingback: Dangerous Delusions: Syria Isn’t Going to Liberate Palestine Anytime Soon nor Is Russia Turning Against “Israel” – Counter Information

  109. Pingback: Netanyahu’s “Operation Greater Israel”? Israel’s Intent to Wage War on Lebanon. – aladdinsmiraclelamp

  110. Pingback: Dangerous Delusions: Syria Isn’t Going to Liberate Palestine Anytime Soon nor Is Russia Turning Against “Israel” |  SHOAH

  111. Pingback: The Kurds Have Backed Damascus Into A Corner | OrientalReview.org

Leave a Reply